Confinement Nanny vs Domestic Helper: What’re the Differences?

‍

The arrival of a newborn in Singapore brings immense joy, but also a significant shift in household dynamics. Many new parents seek extra help during this crucial period by employing foreign domestic workers (FDWs). In fact, there are approximately 286,300 FDWs in Singapore as of 2023, according to Statista.

‍

Two common options are hiring a confinement nanny or a domestic helper, also known as a maid. While both provide domestic assistance, their responsibilities, expertise, and focus differ significantly. 

‍

But what exactly are the differences between a confinement nanny vs a domestic helper/maid? Understanding the distinct roles of a confinement nanny and a domestic helper is crucial for making an informed decision. 

‍

In summary, below are the differentiating factors to consider.

‍

Characteristics of Confinement Nannies

‍

• Specialised training: Confinement nannies often possess specific training and experience in postnatal care and newborn handling.  
• Focus: Primarily on the mother's and newborn's well-being.  
• Higher cost: Due to their specialised skills, confinement nannies usually command higher fees than maids.
• Short-term commitment: Their services are usually required for a limited period, typically a month or two. This short-term nature of a confinement nanny's service allows for focused, intensive support during the crucial initial weeks after birth so the new mother can rest and recover without the burden of chores.

‍

Characteristics of Domestic Helpers/Maids

‍

• General domestic skills: Domestic helpers possess a range of domestic skills, but may lack specialised postnatal care expertise.
• Focus: Primarily on general household management and domestic tasks.
• Lower cost: The cost of hiring a domestic helper is generally lower than hiring a confinement nanny.
• Long-term commitment: They are typically hired on a longer-term basis, providing ongoing support to the household for about two years.

‍

Confinement Nanny

‍

A confinement nanny is a specialist caregiver hired specifically for the postpartum period, typically the first 28 days (or longer, depending on cultural practices). Their primary focus is the well-being of the mother and newborn. 

‍

A confinement nanny’s key responsibilities include:

‍

1. Postnatal Care for Mum

‍

A confinement nanny's role is mainly centered on mummy's recovery.

‍

A significant aspect of this care revolves around the preparation of nutritious confinement meals. These meals, often based on traditional recipes, are designed to replenish the mother's energy, promote lactation, and aid in her overall physical healing. 

‍

Beyond dietary needs, the nanny also provides therapeutic herbal baths and massages, essential for alleviating the aches and pains commonly experienced during the postpartum period.

‍

2. Newborn Care

‍

Equally crucial is the confinement nanny's expertise in newborn care. They are responsible for every aspect of a newborn's daily needs, including feeding, diapering, bathing, and soothing. 

‍

Their care extends to monitoring the baby's health and developmental milestones, ensuring early detection of any potential issues. 

‍

Furthermore, the confinement nanny plays a pivotal role in educating new parents on essential practices with infant care guides and baby tips. This hands-on guidance is invaluable, especially for first-time parents who may feel overwhelmed by the responsibilities of caring for a newborn.

‍

3. Light Household Chores

‍

While the primary focus remains on maternal and infant care, confinement nannies also undertake light household chores directly related to the mother and baby. 

‍

This typically includes tasks such as laundry and cleaning of the baby's items, ensuring a hygienic and comfortable environment for both mother and child. 

‍

Some nannies may also extend their duties to cleaning the kitchen after preparing confinement meals, maintaining a level of cleanliness conducive to the mother's recovery. 

‍

However, their household responsibilities are generally limited. Confinement nannies typically focus on postnatal care and newborn well-being over extensive domestic duties.

‍

Domestic Helper/Maid

A maid, also known as a domestic helper, provides general household assistance. Their responsibilities are broader and not specifically focused on postnatal care.  

‍

A domestic helper’s key responsibilities include:

‍

1. General Household Chores

A maid takes care of the regular chores around the house. This means cleaning, doing laundry, ironing, and cooking meals for the family. These meals are usually regular home cooking, not special confinement food for new mothers. 

‍

If needed, they can also help look after other children or the elderly in the house.

‍

2. Childcare (if experienced)

‍

Some maids have experience looking after kids, but they aren't trained for newborn babies. They are better at helping out with older children, including picking up children from school, taking them to activities, and providing after-school care. This lets parents spend more time with their new baby.

Costs of Hiring a Confinement Nanny vs Domestic Helper/Maid

‍

When hiring a confinement nanny, the costs to consider include:

• Salary (~S$3,000): This is the most significant cost, varying based on experience, demand, number of children (e.g., twins or triplets), and time of the year (e.g., higher during festive periods).
• Red packets (S$200): It's customary to give red packets on the first and last day of the nanny's service.
• Work permit and levy (~S$130): Work permit and levy costs are also included if the confinement nanny is a foreign worker.
• Insurance (~S$60/month): Insurance coverage is optional but also a consideration.
• Food and utilities (~S$150): You'll usually provide the meals and accommodation for your confinement nanny.
• Agency fees (depends on the agency): There may be additional fees if the confinement nanny is hired through an agency.

In total, do expect to pay at least S$3,540 for a confinement nanny. 

What about a domestic helper? Let’s take a look at the breakdown:

• Salary (~S$800 for an experienced helper): Monthly salary, which varies based on experience and nationality.
• Settling In Programme (~S$75): This is a compulsory 1-day orientation programme for all new/first-time FDWs.
• Employer’s Orientation Programme (~S$50): This programme is needed if you’re hiring a FDW for the first time.
• Work permit and levy (~S$130): Costs associated with employing a foreign domestic worker.
• Medical examinations (~S$15/month): Bi-annual medical check-ups are required.
• Insurance (~$60/month): Insurance coverage is mandatory for your domestic helper.
• Food and utilities (~S$150): You'll have to provide the meals and accommodation for your helper.
• Agency fees (depends on the agency): Fees for recruitment and placement.

Adding everything up, it costs at least S$1,115 (monthly costs) + S$125 (one-time costs) = S$1,280 to employ a domestic helper/maid. 

‍

Choosing Between a Confinement Nanny vs Domestic Helper/Maid

‍

By carefully considering your needs and priorities, you can choose the support system that best suits your family during this special time. 

‍

If you:

‍

Prioritise postnatal care: Have a history of difficult deliveries or particularly anxious about newborn care as a first-time mum? A confinement nanny may be the better choice. However, you may not need a confinement nanny if you have family members who can provide support during the postpartum period.

‍

Need general household help: Larger households with multiple children may benefit more from the support of a domestic helper. If you require long-term assistance and childcare for older children, a maid is a more suitable option.

‍

Long-term vs short-term: Confinement nannies work short-term (~1-2 months), while maids are on a long-term contract (~2 years). Consider how comfortable the family is with this.

‍

The Best of Both Worlds

So, confinement nanny vs a domestic helper/maid? 

‍

Why not get both? Some families opt to hire both a confinement nanny and a maid. The nanny focuses on postnatal care for the first month, while the maid provides general household support. 

‍

After the confinement period, the maid continues to assist with household tasks and childcare while the confinement nanny leaves.

‍

What’s most important is to choose a reputable agency like NewBubs Confinement that conducts thorough background checks and provides adequate training. All of our confinement nannies undergo a comprehensive training programme, including hands-on experience at our dedicated confinement centre in Singapore, ensuring they are fully prepared to provide exceptional care in your home.